Receiving a deportation order can be scary. However, in some situations, it may be possible to challenge the decision.
So, who can reverse a deportation order? An order can be overturned by immigration judges, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA), or federal courts.
If you are facing removal from the United States, you need legal representation. An El Paso deportation defense lawyer can review your case, build a defense, and fight for your right to stay in this country.
Who Can Reverse a Deportation Order?
Several different authorities within the U.S. immigration system may overturn a deportation order, including:
- Immigration judges: An immigration judge may reconsider a deportation order if a motion to reopen or reconsider is filed and the court determines that the original decision should be reviewed again.
- The Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA): The BIA is the highest administrative body for interpreting immigration law. As such, it can overturn an immigration judge’s deportation order if an appeal demonstrates legal or factual errors.
- Federal courts: In some cases, you may be able to ask a federal appellate court to review a deportation order after all administrative appeals have been exhausted.
In certain situations, such as when new evidence becomes available or you become eligible for relief, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) may reopen or terminate a removal order.
For a free case evaluation, call +1 (202) 933-3379
How Hard is It to Reverse a Deportation Order?
Several factors affect whether a deportation order can be overturned, including:
- Whether the appeal was filed on time
- The strength of your legal arguments
- The availability of new evidence
- Changes in immigration law
- Your criminal or immigration history
While no outcome is guaranteed, having a lawyer by your side can improve your odds of success.
What Happens if a Deportation Order is Overturned?
If a deportation order is successfully overturned, the case may proceed in several different ways.
Possible outcomes include:
- The case returning to immigration court for further hearings
- You receiving permission to apply for immigration relief
- Termination of removal proceedings
- Approval of a visa, Green Card, or other status (if you are eligible)
In many situations, overturning the order simply reopens the case rather than granting immediate legal status.
Click to contact our immigration lawyers today
How Do Appeals Work in Deportation Cases?
One of the most common ways to challenge a deportation order is through an appeal. Appeals ask a higher authority to review the immigration judge’s decision and determine whether legal mistakes occurred.
The process usually involves these stages:
- Filing the appeal: You must file a notice of appeal within the required time frame (typically within 30 days of the immigration judge’s decision).
- Submitting legal arguments: You must explain why the judge’s decision was incorrect (usually by arguing that the law was applied improperly or that evidence was misunderstood).
- Review by the BIA: The Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) reviews the record of your case and determines whether the immigration judge’s ruling should stand or be reversed.
- Possible further review: If the BIA denies the appeal, you may be able to ask a federal court of appeals to review the decision.
Complete a Free Case Evaluation form now
Can a Deportation Case Be Reopened?
Even after a deportation order becomes final, it may still be possible to reopen the case by filing a motion to reopen. A motion to reopen asks the immigration court to review the case again because new facts or evidence have emerged.
Situations that may justify reopening a deportation case include:
- Newly discovered evidence
- Changes in immigration law that affect your eligibility for relief
- Proof that you did not receive proper notice of the hearing
- Evidence of ineffective assistance of counsel
- Eligibility for a new immigration benefit that was not previously available
If the court grants the motion, the removal order may be reconsidered, and additional proceedings may take place.
What is a Motion to Reconsider?
A motion to reconsider is another legal tool that you may be able to use to challenge a deportation order. Unlike a motion to reopen, this type of motion argues that the judge made a legal or factual mistake when issuing their decision.
A motion to reconsider usually focuses on issues such as:
- Incorrect interpretation of immigration law
- Misapplication of legal standards
- Errors in evaluating the evidence presented during the hearing
If the judge or the BIA agrees that an error occurred, the deportation order may be reversed or modified.
What is Prosecutorial Discretion in Deportation Cases?
In some situations, immigration authorities may choose not to pursue removal even if a deportation order exists. This is known as prosecutorial discretion.
Prosecutorial discretion may involve actions such as:
- Temporarily delaying your deportation
- Reopening or dismissing your case
- Granting deferred action
- Allowing you to remain in the country while you pursue immigration relief
Factors that may influence these decisions include family ties in the United States, length of residence, humanitarian concerns, and lack of criminal history. While prosecutorial discretion does not always erase a deportation order, it may give you additional time to pursue legal relief.
What is a Deportation Order?
A deportation order (also called a removal order) is a formal decision issued by an immigration judge requiring a noncitizen to leave the United States. These orders are typically issued after removal proceedings in immigration court.
Common reasons you may receive a deportation order include:
- Entering the country without authorization
- Overstaying a visa
- Violating visa conditions
- Certain criminal convictions
- Fraud or misrepresentation in immigration applications
Speak to a Deportation Defense Attorney
If you have received a removal order, there’s no time to waste. A deportation defense attorney from Mendoza Law can evaluate your situation, identify opportunities for relief, and advocate for you throughout the appeals process.
Call now to find out how you can stay in the United States.
Call or text +1 (202) 933-3379 or complete a Free Case Evaluation form
